A standard S&P 500 fund fails Islamic screening by default — banks, insurers, leverage. Purpose-built halal ETFs exist; here's how they screen, what they cost, and the trade-offs.
A regular S&P 500 index fund holds banks, insurers, and highly leveraged companies without asking any Islamic finance question at all. That makes the default answer no, but a purpose-built category of halal ETFs exists specifically to fix that, and understanding how they screen holdings explains why two halal funds can still disagree with each other.
A standard index fund buys every company in its benchmark regardless of business activity or balance sheet structure, which means it holds conventional banks, insurers, alcohol and gambling companies, and businesses carrying heavy interest-bearing debt, all without any screening at all. A halal ETF exists specifically to remove those holdings and replace the fund with one that has actually been checked.
Under AAOIFI standards, a company's interest-bearing debt must stay below 30% of its market capitalization, its interest-bearing cash and deposits must stay below 30%, and income from non-compliant sources must stay below 5% of total revenue.
Source: Tabadulat, AAOIFI Standards Explained
A company also has to clear a business activity screen first, meaning it cannot be primarily engaged in alcohol, gambling, conventional banking or insurance, pork, tobacco, or weapons, before its financial ratios are even checked.
Not every screening standard measures the same thing the same way. AAOIFI, Dow Jones Islamic, and S&P Shariah test debt against market capitalization, a number that moves with the stock price. MSCI and FTSE test the same debt against total assets instead, a steadier denominator that does not inflate when a stock rallies. That single difference means a company with comfortable debt against its market cap can still fail an MSCI or FTSE screen, and vice versa, which is exactly why the same stock can sit inside one halal ETF and be missing from another with an almost identical name.
Source: Halal Terminal, Screening Standards Compared
A 2026 study screening 13 major halal ETFs holding by holding found that every major halal equity ETF beat the S&P 500 over the prior 12 months, though the study is explicit that this is a snapshot of one period rather than a guaranteed pattern. The same study found dramatic variation in how strictly individual funds actually screen: 74.7% of SPUS's holdings pass all five major Shariah standards simultaneously, while a specialized real estate fund in the same category passed only 19.5%.
Source: Halal Terminal, State of Halal ETFs 2026
Generally, yes. Halal ETFs typically charge 0.30% to 0.50% a year, against 0.09% to 0.20% for the cheapest conventional equivalents. On a $200,000 portfolio, the gap between a 0.50% halal fund and a 0.20% conventional one adds up to roughly $600 a year, before compounding.

Typical annual expense ratios, halal vs. conventional index funds
Source: LifeMoney, Halal Investing Canada Screening Checklist
Even a fully compliant halal ETF usually still contains a small trace of non-permissible income, since the 5% threshold allows some, not zero. Most scholars require this residue to be purified, meaning the investor calculates the small non-compliant percentage disclosed in the fund's Shariah audit and donates that portion of their return to charity separately, rather than assuming compliance certification alone is the end of the obligation.
Source: HalalScreener, Halal ETFs 2026
//
Be first. Be Able.
Join the waitlist now. UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Qatar launch first. Early users get priority onboarding, locked-in yield rates, and zero fees for the first year.
